Exploring the Differences Between Allegiant and Spirit Airlines

Air travel has become increasingly accessible and affordable thanks to the rise of ultra-low-cost carriers (ULCCs) like Allegiant and Spirit Airlines. While these airlines offer some of the cheapest fares in the industry, they have also garnered a reputation for their no-frills approach and a la carte pricing models. As cost-conscious travelers weigh their options, it’s essential to understand the similarities and differences between these two budget airlines.

Business Models and Pricing Strategies

Both Allegiant and Spirit Airlines operate under the ULCC business model, which aims to keep base fares as low as possible by unbundling services and charging additional fees for amenities like carry-on bags, seat selection, and in-flight refreshments. However, there are some notable differences in their pricing strategies.

Allegiant Airlines primarily focuses on leisure travelers, offering nonstop flights to popular vacation destinations from smaller, underserved airports. This approach allows them to minimize overhead costs and pass those savings on to customers. However, their limited flight schedules and irregular routes can make it challenging for travelers to find convenient options.

Spirit Airlines, on the other hand, offers a more extensive network, serving major airports across the United States, Mexico, Latin America, and the Caribbean. While their base fares may be slightly higher than Allegiant’s, they provide more flexibility in terms of flight schedules and destinations.

Fees and Additional Charges

One of the most significant factors to consider when choosing between Allegiant and Spirit Airlines is the potential for additional fees. Both airlines charge for carry-on bags, checked luggage, seat selection, and in-flight refreshments, but the specifics of these fees can vary.

Allegiant Airlines’ fees for carry-on bags and checked luggage are generally lower than Spirit’s, ranging from $10 to $60 for carry-ons and $25 to $60 for checked bags, depending on the route and when the fees are paid. Spirit’s fees, on the other hand, can be as high as $65 for carry-ons and $100 for checked bags.

When it comes to seat selection, Allegiant offers a more affordable option, with fees starting at $5 for standard seats and $25 for exit row seats. Spirit’s seat selection fees range from $12 to $199, depending on the seat type and flight duration.

In-flight refreshments are another area where Allegiant and Spirit Airlines differ. Allegiant offers a more extensive menu, including alcoholic beverages, while Spirit’s in-flight offerings are limited to snacks and non-alcoholic beverages.

Flight Experience and Onboard Amenities

While both Allegiant and Spirit Airlines prioritize cost savings over luxurious amenities, there are some differences in the overall flight experience.

Allegiant Airlines operates a fleet of Airbus A319 and A320 aircraft, which are generally newer and more fuel-efficient than Spirit’s fleet of Airbus A320 and A321 aircraft. However, Spirit’s cabins are often configured with more seats, resulting in tighter legroom and less personal space.

In terms of in-flight entertainment, neither airline offers complimentary options. Allegiant relies on passengers bringing their own devices, while Spirit offers a pay-per-view system for movies, TV shows, and games.

Baggage Policies and Handling

Baggage policies and handling are critical considerations for travelers, especially those planning extended trips or carrying larger luggage.

Allegiant Airlines allows one personal item (up to 16″ x 15″ x 7″) to be carried on free of charge, while Spirit Airlines permits one personal item (up to 18″ x 14″ x 8″) to be brought on board without a fee. Any additional carry-on bags will incur fees from both airlines.

When it comes to checked baggage, Allegiant Airlines has a weight limit of 40 pounds per bag, while Spirit Airlines allows bags up to 50 pounds. Overweight and oversized bag fees may apply.

It’s worth noting that Allegiant Airlines has faced criticism in the past for high rates of mishandled baggage, while Spirit Airlines has generally performed better in this area.

Safety and Reliability

Safety is a paramount concern for any traveler, and both Allegiant and Spirit Airlines have faced scrutiny regarding their safety records and operational reliability.

Allegiant Airlines has been the subject of several investigations and reports questioning its maintenance practices and safety protocols. In 2016, the airline faced intense scrutiny after a series of mechanical issues and emergency landings, leading to a comprehensive review by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). While Allegiant has addressed these concerns and implemented changes, some travelers may still have reservations about their safety record.

Spirit Airlines, on the other hand, has generally maintained a better safety record than Allegiant, with fewer incidents and FAA enforcement actions. However, the airline has faced criticism for its operational reliability, with high rates of flight delays and cancellations.

Customer Service and Satisfaction

Customer service and satisfaction are often areas where ultra-low-cost carriers like Allegiant and Spirit Airlines struggle to excel. Their focus on cost-cutting measures can sometimes come at the expense of customer experience.

Both airlines have received low ratings from customers in various customer satisfaction surveys, with complaints ranging from unfriendly staff to hidden fees and poor communication during delays or cancellations.

However, it’s worth noting that individual experiences can vary, and some travelers have reported positive interactions with the airlines’ staff and appreciation for the low fares.

Conclusion

Choosing between Allegiant and Spirit Airlines ultimately comes down to personal preferences, travel needs, and budget considerations. While both airlines offer affordable fares, their approaches to pricing, amenities, and customer service can differ significantly.

For travelers prioritizing rock-bottom prices and willing to forego traditional amenities, Allegiant Airlines may be the more appealing option, particularly for leisure travel to popular vacation destinations. However, its limited flight schedules and safety concerns may deter some travelers.

Spirit Airlines, on the other hand, offers a more extensive network and potentially better operational reliability, but at slightly higher base fares and with the potential for additional fees.

Ultimately, it’s crucial for travelers to carefully evaluate their specific needs, weigh the pros and cons of each airline, and make an informed decision. By understanding the differences between Allegiant and Spirit Airlines, travelers can better manage their expectations and make the most of their travel budget.